Home > Ohio > Cedar Point > Top Thrill Dragster > Review Comments


 Review of Top Thrill Dragster @ Cedar Point
5 Rating Posted by: Timberman on 9/21/2004 9:30:00 PM
This is a difficult review to write, because my score would be different depending on whether I rated TTD in the broad category of "thrill rides" or reviewed it as a roller coaster. Rather than get into that argument, and for the sake of simplicity, Ill take my cue from Cedar Points own marketing strategy and rate it as a roller coaster.

Even for a seasoned, slightly jaded coaster enthusiast, TTD is intimidating. The way I felt standing in line for TTD was similar to the way I felt standing in line for SFOGs GASM at age 8. It kind of puts you in that place where you think that nothing in your experience can quite prepare you for what youre about to do. Recapturing that feeling is priceless and what I hope for year after year when new rides are built.

TTDs lines are long, but the day I went (18.09.04), several trains were running, and the line moved at a reasonable pace. I waited about 90 minutes for a seat in the front, but I didnt mind. I enjoyed watching the ride, seeing the reactions of people as they returned to the station, listening to the Elvis music, and talking to other TTD newcomers. The anticipation TTD evokes makes for an unsual amount of friendly, communal, and nervous banter in the queue. Although Im not big on themeing, my hats off to Cedar Point for the drag racing concept, which is very appropriate and adds to the atmosphere of speed and excitement.

So far so good. Really, I cant say anything negative about any single aspect of the ride. Weve all been on launched coasters by now, but never like this, and that long straightaway lets you feel like Evel Kneviel on his Skycycle. The transition to the tower is absolutely seamless, and the ascent is incredibly fast, yet the immense size of the ride lets you experience the varying sensations of each section. Time-consuming rollbacks nothwithstanding, the short pause (or at least deceleration) at the apex of the hill provides a moment to take in the view, throw up your hands, or utter a prayer. Then youre into a vertical, 400, corkscrew dive, followed by another seamless transition into the brake run, by which time youre singing, "I am / I am Superman / And I can do anything" or something similar. Its the most intense 18 or so seconds to be had in the park, and an indispensible experience for thrill-seekers of all persuasions.

Yet having done it, I was content to move on. This is difficult to explain, but the classic coasters foster a relationship and keep you coming back again and again. They have sublety, variety, and personality, and each ride on them is a different and rewarding experience. TDD is a conquest, a trophy coaster, but you dont settle down with it. This is the coaster you ride to tell your friends you rode it, and its charms, while considerable, are also somewhat superficial. If height and speed were all that coasters were about, then wed all be writing to each other on a skydiving website. Lets face it, when engineering science gives us the 500-foot, 175 mph launch coaster, TTD will go the way of the Laser Loop, but people will still be lining up for the Coney Island Cyclone, just as they have since 1927. Thats the difference between the latest technology and enduring design genius. TTD has plenty of the former but not much of the latter, so I cant rate it as a classic.
 

Review Comments

BobFunland on 9/21/2004 10:41:50 PM said:
I think that this is a good review, and it reiterates what I said below. I couldnt agree more with you about the "TTD is a conquest... but you dont settle down with it" comment. My biggest problem with the coaster is that it was a launch and a top hat, and nothing else. I didnt bother to ride it a second time because I felt that it wasnt worth a wait for a second ride.

I noticed you mentioned riding GASM when you were 8? Is SFOG your home park?

Oh, and welcome to the site. You supported your beliefs very well, so hopefully no one will give you bad comments
adriahna on 9/21/2004 11:16:55 PM said:
Very, very well-written review - and you have some seriously valid points. I havent been on TTD as of yet, but I still have a great appreciation for what you have to say here. Also, of course - welcome to the site!!!
Timberman on 9/21/2004 11:31:45 PM said:
Thanks. Ive lived all over the place, but Ill always consider Coney Island in Brooklyn my home park. Im in the Midwest now and looking forward to riding all the famous Heartland coasters Ive read so much about (Beast, Legend, Shivering Timbers, etc.). Im not here to knock TDD, and I had a good experience with it, but is it a coaster for the ages? No. Would anyone care if they took it down if they built something 25 taller? No.
larrygator on 9/22/2004 12:10:39 AM said:
good review rookie, welcome

m311ton on 9/22/2004 1:06:30 AM said:
Awesome review, its nice to see someone bring up those points on a ride that is often times overrated in the sense that it it wasnt one of a kind, it wouldnt be too special. Im looking forward to reading more of your reviews.
BobFunland on 9/22/2004 11:46:36 AM said:
^you bring up a good point- if the rocket at SFGAdv is just like TTD except taller, Id imagine that the ratings wont be as good because it isnt original. TTDs ratings may be affected too, which is why I believe it will not be a mainstay in the Top 10 for too long, but until someone else builds something to the effect of Millennium Force, it will remain up there, seeing as there are no other 300 hypers (operating...)
m311ton on 9/22/2004 7:05:53 PM said:
Its a pretty signifigant bias in the rankings, but its also a very difficult one to factor out. I know Mark does a lot of work to try and keep rankings as fair as humanly possible, but does he do anything to take that factor into consideration? That would be interesting.
papa1958 on 9/28/2004 1:56:23 PM said:
Thank you for this thoughtful (dare I say poetic) review. A wonderful companion to your recent review of the Coney Island Cyclone. Welcome to the website.
BobFunland on 10/3/2004 10:05:44 PM said:
Superman: The Escape at Magic Mountian is actually much worse than the Dragster, at least TTD accelarates faster than my car LOL
BobFunland on 10/3/2004 10:41:06 PM said:
Why dont you join the site
BobFunland on 10/4/2004 10:29:59 AM said:
I would suggest emailing the webmaster (the address is on the bottom of all of the pages) and telling him about your dilemma
Scott on 11/8/2004 6:36:47 PM said:
Thanks Bob I am now on the site writing reviews.
Scott on 11/24/2004 7:19:29 PM said:
How could you have gone on King da Ka when its not even open yet! You liked space Mountain better then this? I think all of your posts are bogus. You didnt even find the launch good? Bogus And no its not a chat room, you should join the site. But just dont lie about kingda ka
coaster05 on 11/25/2004 12:49:47 AM said:
Kingda Ka is open man he must be like the first person to ride it. Gee cant we all wait for this tool to join our site. I told you bob that the message board gods will punish for our run of good new members here comes that uberidiot:fire:
Scott on 11/29/2004 10:18:14 AM said:
Its open?! LOL Are you joking?
BobFunland on 11/29/2004 2:06:45 PM said:
This would be the uber. the creme de la creme, but not quite on the Dahli Lama Level of nemmy.
Scott on 11/29/2004 5:50:29 PM said:
Well it doesnt seem like hes come back yet. we should just keep our fingers crossed. :critic:
Post Review Comment
You must login or create an account to post a review comment.

 
Clicky Web Analytics